Home » SEO Metrics to Track: 10 That Actually Matter (and 4 That Don’t)

SEO Metrics to Track: 10 That Actually Matter (and 4 That Don’t)

SEO Metrics to Track: 10 That Actually Matter (and 4 That Don’t)
Table Of Contents

SEO Metrics to Track: 10 That Actually Matter (and 4 That Don’t)

Search Engine Optimization is a long-term game. But without tracking the right metrics, you’ll have no idea whether you’re winning, losing, or just standing still. Not all SEO metrics are created equal—some reveal true performance and opportunities, while others are misleading or downright useless.

This guide breaks down the 10 SEO metrics that actually matter—and 4 you can probably ignore. If you want to measure what moves the needle, this is what you need to watch.

10 SEO Metrics That Actually Matter

1. Organic Traffic


This is the most critical metric to track—it tells you how many users are reaching your site via non-paid search results. It’s a direct reflection of your SEO efforts and shows whether they’re bringing real visitors.

Monitor overall trends, then segment by landing page, country, device, and keyword. Look for meaningful growth over time.

👉 How to track it: Use Google Search Console → Performance tab or Google Analytics → Traffic Acquisition > Organic Search.

2. Keyword Rankings


Tracking keyword positions shows whether your pages are climbing or dropping in the search results. Fluctuations are normal, but continuous improvement signals effective SEO.

Focus on keywords with high business value—those that drive qualified traffic and conversions. But don’t obsess over individual rankings; always tie them back to traffic and revenue.

👉 How to track it: Use keyword tracking tools to monitor key terms over time. Group them by topic or intent for clarity.

3. Click-Through Rate (CTR)


CTR tells you how compelling your result is on the SERP. A low CTR despite high rankings could mean your title tag, meta description, or structured data needs improvement.

Improving CTR can drive more traffic without increasing your rankings—a high-leverage optimization.

👉 How to track it: Google Search Console → Performance tab → Filter by page or query. Look for keywords with good positions but low CTR.

4. Bounce Rate


Bounce rate shows how many users leave a page without taking action or visiting another page. While it’s not a direct ranking factor, a high bounce rate can signal that your content doesn’t match user intent—or it’s just plain bad.

Context matters. A blog post answering a quick question may have a high bounce rate and still be successful. Always interpret bounce rate along with time on page and conversion rate.

👉 How to track it: Google Analytics → Behavior → Site Content → Landing Pages.

5. Conversions from Organic Traffic


SEO success isn’t just about traffic—it’s about business impact. Monitor how many of your organic visitors become leads, customers, or subscribers.

Define what a conversion looks like on your site and set up goal tracking. This helps you prioritize the SEO tasks that actually drive revenue.

👉 How to track it: Google Analytics → Conversions → Multi-Channel Funnels → Assisted Conversions + Last Click conversions.

6. Indexed Pages


If a page isn’t indexed, it won’t show up in the search results. Tracking the number of indexed pages helps you spot underperforming or excluded content.

Look for patterns—are pages being excluded because of low quality, technical issues, or crawling problems?

👉 How to track it: Google Search Console → Coverage report → Valid & Excluded tabs.

7. Page Speed (Core Web Vitals)


Faster pages lead to better UX—and better rankings. Core Web Vitals, including Largest Contentful Paint (LCP), First Input Delay (FID), and Cumulative Layout Shift (CLS), measure real-world performance.

Improving site speed can boost organic rankings, particularly on mobile.

👉 How to track it: Google Search Console → Core Web Vitals report / PageSpeed Insights.

8. Backlinks


Backlinks remain one of the most important ranking factors. The number, quality, and relevance of referring domains all impact your ability to rank.

Rather than fixate on total backlink count, focus on acquiring links from authoritative sources in your niche. These move rankings, not low-quality directory links or spammy blog comments.

👉 How to track it: Use a backlink analysis tool to monitor referring domains, lost links, domain authority, and anchor text distribution.

9. Crawl Errors


If search engines can’t crawl your site properly, your content won’t get indexed or ranked. Crawl issues like broken internal links, server errors, or blocked resources must be fixed quickly.

Good technical health is foundational to scalable SEO.

👉 How to track it: Google Search Console → Coverage + Crawl Stats reports / Server logs.

10. Content Efficiency


Content efficiency measures how many of your published pages actually bring in traffic or conversions. Publishing more content isn’t the goal—ranking content is.

Use this metric to evaluate your content ROI and prune underperforming pages that waste crawl budget and dilute link equity.

👉 How to track it: Export content URLs and match against traffic/conversion data. Calculate ratio of active vs. inactive pages.

4 SEO Metrics That Don’t Matter (Much)

Not all metrics are helpful. These are often misinterpreted or don’t correlate with real SEO performance.

1. Domain Authority (DA) or Domain Rating (DR)


These are third-party metrics and not used by Google in rankings. While they offer a rough benchmark, they’re easily manipulated and should not be a KPI.

Useful for prospecting (e.g. comparing backlink profiles), but don’t optimize blindly for them.

2. Total Backlinks


Backlinks matter—but total backlink count is not helpful without context. Thousands of low-quality links won’t help and might hurt.

Always focus on referring domains and link quality over volume.

3. Pages per Session


This is often cited as a UX metric, but it’s not very actionable and depends heavily on content type. Some pages should be stand-alone. Optimizing for more page views can backfire by degrading experience.

Only useful when context is well understood (e.g. SaaS onboarding).

4. Keyword Density


This metric is stuck in 2005. Google doesn’t use keyword frequency as a ranking factor in isolation. Stuffing keywords won’t help—it’ll hurt.

Focus on satisfying search intent and using semantically relevant language—natural language wins over arbitrary keyword metrics.

Final Thoughts

Effective SEO measurement is about separating signal from noise. Metrics like organic traffic, keyword rankings, and conversions show whether your tactics are working. Others might waste your time, lead you astray, or feed vanity.

Track what drives business results and use those insights to prioritize what to do next. That’s how you build sustainable, high-impact SEO.

Senior SEO-specialist
Hi, I'm Mark and I have been in the SEO industry for a while. I get a kick out of helping businesses gain organic visibility, and even better, more organic conversions.
Contact
Szlak 77/222
30-392, Kraków
Poland

info@eastfielddigital.com
© 2025 Eastfield Digital. All rights reserved.